Showing posts with label business. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Do Public Schools Serve the Common Good?

Diane Ravitch, in her newest book, Reign of Error, writes that public schools are for the common good, but John Taylor Gatto argues that they were  meant to serve the needs of the ruling class, by teaching the kids of lower socioeconomic classes to conform. It's been my own experience advocating for my children when they were in school that teaching kids to conform  still is the major goal, or else schools would look  very different indeed!

kindergartenMany excellent books have been written about how kids learn best, but these have been, and are still, ignored by those working in this institution. Why? Because those who are in control of society do not want kids to learn what is best for themselves. They certainly do not want kids to become critical thinkers and prudent consumers. The global economy depends on their participation, and schools help with that. How? By getting kids involved in competition as soon as they enter, with awards, grades and rewards, and now also awards for scoring well on the state standardized tests!

We are fed sound bites that a good education is important for getting a good job or career, but only a fraction of people will be rewarded with a job that pays well enough and that they like! It is not about getting a good mind that you can and SHOULD put to use to help create a better society along with others who have good minds and caring hearts too.

Kids are raised and 'educated' to be materialistic consumers, and it is working. Schools even play along by providing kids with the latest technology and software programs, ignoring that the best brain is developed by means of  tactile learning opportunities indoors and out, rather than through 'fun' apps on iPads, now provided to kindergarteners who then only get to use one finger to manipulate the screen instead of using all ten, digging in the dirt and sculpting clay.

It's ironic how all who love digital gadgets and games, and see no harm in that use, have inadvertently helped set the stage for the disappearance of the teacher. That is what the reforms are now all about; computers, standardized tests, common core standards measurable by tests on computers, and the use of iPads and smart boards. Think of the companies making money on all these things that are really not good for young, developing brains!

Frank Smith warned about it almost 30 years ago! No one listened!
"..The computer is the ultimate weapon of instructional programmers, and in many people’s minds at least, it is a device to take the place of teachers. Anyone who believes that students learn best from systematic instruction and tests can say goodbye to teachers. For dispensing programmatic instruction, computers are cheaper and more efficient than humans.

..Our schools should not remain places where the enormous potential of the human brain is systematically eroded, and possibly destroyed. The invasion of education by instructional programmers must be turned back now.”

We probably won't unless the power grid goes out for good!
--------------------------------------------------------

Discuss Diane's book with others on the Facebook group: Opt Out of the State Test: The National Movement



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4eYRPjfGYQ

Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Learning is Knowing what Questions to ask.

By Angela Engel 

"....As the business community delves into the complexities of education, they may want to look a little more deeply at the tests that are driving everything in education.


I first administered the Colorado Student Assessment Program (CSAP) test to my fourth grade students in 1997. High stakes testing was the reason I left the classroom and the reason I have not returned.  Why? Because I knew that a year’s worth of “Joe’s” writing is a much greater indicator of his writing ability than one CSAP essay graded by a temp worker.

Hearing “Lisa” discuss character development in a literature discussion with her peers or reading her annotated notes is far more revealing than how she answered the question, “Who is the main character in this paragraph?”

A: Dick

B: Sally

C: Rover

D: All of the above

Reviewing questions that “Mike” generated on his own from a science experiment on volume tells much more about his understanding than how he answered question number thirteen on the state assessment.
In real life, the questions aren’t given to us. The most important part of learning is knowing what questions to ask. 

What we learned from the recently released CSAP scores was the same thing we learned from the first tests: That students who have more opportunity and resources do better than students who do not. Socio-economic-status is the number one correlating factor to test scores.

We also learned that high-stakes testing does not better prepare our children for college. Remediation rates are three times higher than when No Child Left Behind was signed by Congress.
The class of 2011 — the first class to graduate under high-stakes testing — showed an 11 percent increase from the previous year in the need for college remediation, according to the Colorado Commission on Higher Education.

It is simple, really. The students who have been educated under the umbrella of high-stakes testing did not get the opportunity to fall in love with books or to develop their own writing style and voice. They were too busy memorizing testing terminology and mastering test-taking strategies to engage in serious reading or writing on interesting concepts that have meaning in their own lives.

State assessments did not close the achievement gap as promised. Instead, we traded educational opportunity for data spreadsheets, and now there are twice as many children in poverty. The number of homeless schoolchildren in this state has more than tripled in the past 10 years — from 7,000 to more than 23,300 students last school year.

Meanwhile, the majority of our elected representatives continue to insist that learning can be forced on students with the “right” test. They argue that teachers will do better if their evaluations are tied to the tests, as if educators care more about their own ratings than they do about the kids they serve day in and day out.

While Colorado spends another year choking on the data, classrooms grow larger and teachers and school counselors become fewer. Test prep and remediation courses have replaced music, art and PE, after-school programs, and field trips. Still we wonder why kids will not stay in school and more are diagnosed with anxiety and depression. Students are now being tested in preschool and kindergarten, despite all evidence that standardized tests in early grades is developmentally inappropriate.

Now, the Colorado state Board of Education  has adopted the Common Core, yet another set of standards now being implemented in schools where some haven’t been able to afford new text books for decades.

Standardized tests are not an accurate measure of what students and teachers can do. Even if they were, the purpose of education is not to measure human capabilities, the purpose is to advance them. Millions of taxpayer dollars have been wasted on testing reforms that have diverted our time, attention and resources away from addressing the opportunity gap and infusing innovation.

Parents do not need school performance ratings based on a test; they need schools that are safe, happy, holistic, and promote personal, real learning. Teachers do not need a test to tell them how they or their students are performing; they need tools, resources and time.

And business does not need future employees who are experts at shading bubbles.

Friday, January 27, 2012

Schools in the Plastic Age

Welcome to the PC  (Plastic and Computer) Age kindergarten where kids no longer play.




(Phot0: Denver Post,  Jan. 17, 2012; a kindergarten class at the Ricardo Flores Magon Academy K-8 charter school in Westminster.)

Standardized test scores say nothing about a student's creative ability or potential. If curriculum focuses on prescribed skills, that is what students will learn, but nothing beyond. If kids are taught to read by means of a rigid script and in a lock-step curriculum, they will not be able to stretch their minds beyond the script or facts taught.

If children in kindergarten are not allowed to play and socialize, they will not function well in 21st Century jobs because they'll lack the imagination to come up with innovations, and the skills to work together. Schools will turn out uncaring individuals who will speed up the destruction of the natural world instead of saving it.

How many people today know about the dangers of plastic particles that are now a permanent part of our environment, and even our bodies? How many adults unthinkingly heat up food in plastic containers? Do you? Even Gerber now puts baby food in plastic jars!

Paula Johanson in her book for teens,  Frequently Asked Questions About Testicular Cancer, writes:
"...there is "a significant elevated risk of testicular cancer..linked to exposure to polyvinyl chloride.. and other "plastic" materials that release estrogen-mimic chemicals into food and water."

Why is it that we are not made aware of the poisoning of ourselves and our children?  Our own education did not help us prevent it. Back then too little was known. That is different now, yet schools still do not teach how to deal with, and survive a poisoned world!


Corporations, of course, don't want people to become knowledgeable about the negative impact and even damage that many of their products pose on people and the environment . As Edward Luttwak remarks in his book, Turbo-Capitalism; Winners and Losers in the Global Economy,
"Corporations are not moral entities. They exist to make a profit."

Indeed, with  No Child Left Behind-- initiated by the Business Roundtable-- schools were coerced into testing students to hold schools accountable for receiving education money. If test scores were low, rigid improvement measures were forced upon them.  Profits for textbook and test publishers soared! McGraw-Hill alone saw an increase from 50 million dollars in 2002 when NCLB was just enacted, to 300 million dollars by 2009.

As long as corporations implicitly dictate what and how schools should teach, we can never have quality education. Children will not be taught to think critically and to question, but instead will be molded into the corporations' future workforce and consumers who will mindlessly continue to poison the environment. Schools still drill and test, rather than develop understanding of the importance of sustainable living. As one teacher shared in a survey,
"We need to get our kids to care, because these are the issues that they will be dealing with for the rest of their lives."

Are we?

Watch this six minute clip:

12-year-old Severn Suzuki speaking at the Rio Earth Summit

Of note also:

 

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Well-Paying Jobs Will be Few!

If only people, especially those in business, including students majoring in business, would read books like “Turbo-Capitalism: Winners and Losers in the Global Economy” by Edward Luttwak, they would realize that only a small number of all the envisioned “proficient” students will ultimately find a slot away from the base of the pyramid that is capitalism!

Well-paying high-tech jobs requiring advanced math and science will be few. Yet, Bill Gates and others believe it necessary that kids are pushed in that direction whether it is their area of strength, or love, or not!
Why do we even believe this hype, when according to BBC World News corporate America is already investing money in research and development labs in China, therewith supporting the graduates over there instead of here?
China has over 1,200,000 IT professionals and is adding 400,000 technical graduates each year. China ranks #1 in the world (followed by India and the US)  ~ Source: Facts About China: education

See China's Drive to Promote Invention.
"..multinational firms are now betting that the long-term future of innovation may lie in China. Hundreds of companies have opened research centres in Beijing and Shanghai.

Intel has its own compound in a skyscraper in Beijing, where dozens of young researchers doodle on notepads or write incomprehensible programmes onto their computer screens.

Intel's strategy is simple - sign up the best young brains in China and then get them to have a go at some mind-bending problems, such as face processing imaging, machinery application on video retrieval and ultra-mobile devices."

It’s not because there are no smart graduates here as we are supposed to believe. It’s because investing in Chinese graduates and labs is cheaper! Having more science and math majors here is not going to change that. Luttwak writes “Corporations are not moral entities. They exist to earn profits.”

Indeed! They are opportunists, lacking allegiance to their own country, fellow citizens and even their own employees which they easily lay off under the guise of “restructuring.” At a later time they rehire, but at lower wages and offering fewer benefits! They are powerful entities. According to David Downing in an educational book about and called "Capitalism",
"The most important changes to affect the international economy over the last 25 years has been the rise of multinational corporations. These businesses, which conduct operations all over the world, can have more money than some national governments...

supporters claim that they bring new technology..and new jobs to the poorer countries..[but] ..critics argued that the jobs are few, the major decisions all made at corporate headquarters in the rich countries, and that most of the profits are sent home."

Clearly corporations will employ any strategy that promises profit, including outsourcing which has nothing to do with the talent pool stateside, but with savings.

Writes Luttwak : “ ... even at the height of the boom in 1997, there was still an oversupply of software engineers in general, so much so that employers could pick and choose among job applicants, specifically picking the young who cost less, while rejecting mid-career applicants - not something they could afford to do if there were a shortage.”

As an example, since 1997 Microsoft has only hired 2% of all software writing applicants! The other dozen or so smaller software companies hire even fewer which leaves more than 70% of qualified people without a job of their choice! That’s what “business” hopes No Child Left Behind will “produce” — an oversupply of qualified human resources for any field in which large profits can be made to drive down wages and generate more profit. And profit for whom? For the CEOs and the stockholders!